Rambling

Book Thoughts: Braiding Sweetgrass by Robin Wall Kimmer

I finally got around to reading this book, which is cited in basically everything that mentions indigenous science. Despite having gotten myself a physical copy, I didn't actually manage to read it for years. In the end, realizing that I would have to do something different to actually read it, I got both the ebook (to read on my phone when I'm outside) and borrowed the audiobook on Hoopla (so I could listen to it while drawing). This worked, because evidently, I actually only want to read when I don't have things I find more fun available to me, and I hate lugging heavy things around.

I do think this book was useful for me to read, specifically in teaching me what a gift economy actually is, and answering a long-standing question I had every time I heard someone talk about honoring their ancestors. Why would you want to honor dead people that have both good and bad, some of whom are inevitably abusers and the like? I can't think of a single person in my biological family I'd like to honor. I remember asking this question to my therapist about what people actually meant about that before, and they told me that they pick and choose which ancestors to honor. This made sense, granted that we'll never get along with nor be grateful for every person who has ever walked on earth, bloodline or not.

This is relevant because there was also another question I've had about indigenous ways of being with the land: Do they really value every single type of life from every species out there? Surely that can't be the case as humans are bound to prioritize their own species and therefore cull ones that are actively harming them. I've always wondered about this, especially with the discourse about what counts as a native species. And why do native species have a greater right to life and land if every life out there (plant, animal, etc.) has an exactly equal worth? — which, if don't believe in spirituality, is actually none inherent at all, just that we choose to assign worth to things that we like, most obviously other humans. I was wondering this whole time if it was purely utilitarian, in that native species support the most diversity of life in the areas they've adapted to, so therefore it maximizes the space we have if we prioritize them and kill invasive ones, which often strip resources (perhaps to their own detriment, and some analogues are definitely made in this book between colonizers and invasive plants and animals). And what about the fact that we need to kill to survive? Vegans have long tried to opt out of this core dilemma of being by claiming that plants don't feel pain and don't matter because they're basically machines, which is a cope based on human-centric ideas of life and distress signals that "matter."

In summary, in the indigenous worldview, plants, animals, etc. are all peoples, just like humans are peoples. However, not all peoples are equally obligated to each other. What matters are the relationships, that is to say, whether or not peoples are helping each other mutually flourish. Not all peoples are your peoples, just like not all ancestors are ones you choose to honor. This view of relationships is both spiritually grounded as well as highly practical in producing behavior that mutually sustains multiple species — without leading the world to a climate disaster, one might add.

The idea of the gift economy much works in this way — gifts are given freely because gifts circulating ensures the survival of everyone, and creating a culture of gratitude curbs worldviews like consumerism, which then leads to sustainability and also a sense of belonging for the individual in a world. Lots of destructive worldviews like the various strains of fascism believe in a zero-sum game, in a world that is inherently hostile that must be conquered lest the self be extinguished. This is the exact opposite of the belief that the world you live in is sustained by gifts from the land around you, where you have the ability to give back in the small ways you can, as part of the cycle of existence. Admittedly, living in a world that feels inherently beautiful and kind sounds like a worldview that has the greater chance of producing peace and harmony, in the individual and between peoples.

(Two quick caveats, of course: 1) Indigenous peoples aren't a monolith and certain peoples have fought against each other. So it's not like a gift-giving economy is a 100% guarantee, partly because — 2) the moment you have any bad actor who wants to hoard resources, they gain an upper hand in a world that cannot escape the facts on the ground that the people alive get to decide what the world looks like. This is how colonialism and settlers have prevailed in our current moment, though our days are definitely numbered. Violence is an inescapable fact of life, in one of the greatest problems of life on this planet: to stop violence, you actually need a threat of force. However, this means that your peoples have to know how to use violence. But once you know how to use violence, then the likelihood of using it goes up, much like how having a gun in the home drastically increases the chances that someone will be shot. The day people solve this is the day humanity stops being so damned depressing for pessimists like me.)

At some point, I was hoping to read a book on Yupik culture because I saw this concept of animals "giving" their lives to human hunters mentioned in some other book I was reading. I never actually got around to opening that book (nor researching the author to make sure that it wasn't an exploitative text), but I'd always been wondering about that as well because it also seemed like an extremely arrogant human way of thinking, that any living thing would want to die for humans, when humans aren't exactly walking up to offer themselves to be mauled by bears. This text was actually able to answer this question for me. No matter what pedantic quibbles I may have with the framing that any other life on this planet would willingly die for humans — due to coming from the western science view that views evolution broadly as a filtering process that relies on a species' desire to live and propagate (as species that don't, therefore die out) — viewing the lives you take to survive as a gift that you need to honor accomplishes two things. First, if practiced correctly from a sense of shared abundance rather than evidence of one's superiority, it promotes natural incentive to avoid overtaxing and exhausting others' lives (aka natural resources); secondly, it ironically avoids anthropocentric liabilities found in both factory farming and mainstream veganism, which both operate on the assumption that it is all right to be careless with some lives and view them as a numbers game to extract (animals and plants to factory farming; plants to vegans).

So, do I agree that this world and various peoples in it are in gift-giving relationships to each other, that at times include their lives? No, but I have yet to hear of worldview (that is actually successfully held by a community of people rather than an individualized belief) that both admits that we need to kill other beings to live and that actively curbs extractionist behaviors, all the while holding an optimistic view of humanity's capabilities and place among the land. This worldview will not ever be mine as someone who has 0 spirituality, but I do respect it and would rather people believe in this than Christianity or capitalist mindsets shared by atheist scientists.

This worldview is best presented in their creation story of Skywoman, which is one where gifts are given freely. The book does a good comparison to the creation story of Eve, which is the opposite in that Adam & Eve are cast out of Heaven into an uncaring world that they have to conquer in order to go back to their rightful place. Meanwhile, the world of Skywoman's is already nurturing, her people are here to stay and live in harmony. Creation stories have generally bored me, but I found this contrast more effective, especially in seeing what is specifically lacking in the creation stories of the Abrahamic religions.

Something else this book also really made me think about was the default lens I have from dominant science, which is that humans aren't really factored into plant survival and the best way to care for an ecosystem is to leave the plants alone. Specifically, I've felt bad about the idea of killing plants in general for human activities that aren't strictly related to eating. This book argues that some plants need humans to manage them, including killing them sometimes, in order for them to propagate more. For instance, the Sweetgrass of the book's title has a section in which Kimmer talks about indigenous research that found that indigenous harvesting of Sweetgrass, which can include pulling them up entirely by the root, is actually necessary for the plant to survive, because doing so scatters its seeds. Sweetgrass as a species dies in places where indigenous communities aren't living because of the difference in this practice specifically. This got me thinking about gardening and pruning of shrubs and tree cutting and if any specific practices are actually beneficial to the plants even if they don't seem to be. Even mowing of grass was mentioned as beneficial here, because the grass needs to be picked to propagate. This runs counter to western science narratives about, "Actually, that newly mowed scent is of the grass crying because it's a I'm in pain thing," and I'm not entirely sure what to make of it.

I guess something that I'm thinking about is that often with humans, we look at what benefits the individual (such as human rights being on an individual-based framework), and any individual suffering in a way that can be prevented is an injustice. However, the framework presented here for plants is one that takes their long-term ability to survive as the foremost basis for whether they are being treated correctly. I'm thinking about how cutting off a human's limb is something that someone can't come back from in the same way as how some plants can regrow some branches or leaves. Is the temporary suffering of having a piece of its body being cut worth it to the plant, if it can grow stronger from it? That's my anthrocentric question of the day. (Because what even is a plant as an individual.)

Otherwise, the book seems to struggle with the idea of how we're all complicit in the market economy, but it's very hard to opt out individually. I was honestly surprised that Kimmer didn't just bring up organizing as something we should all theoretically get involved with to shift this. Rather, it was more focused on the individual experience and trying to cultivate an appreciation for the land in the reader, I feel. She talks about how humans aren't the only teachers, beings like mountains (regarded as dead in dominant science) and trees are, too.

This is convincing to me, but I still refuse to hang out in nature more than I need to until someone finds a fix for my skin being overreactive to various biting bugs. When I really sat down and thought about why I am afraid of a lot of varieties of bugs, it basically comes down to childhood memories of what feels like having my bodily autonomy taken away by allergic reactions (losing the ability to bend a limb from mosquito bites) from a crowd of small things that I can't adequately protect myself from, and I can't even spot when it happens. Any bugs that infest thus become overlaid with this problem, because it feels like I have to go nuclear or else I'm screwed and my body will pay the price (hence why fleas drive me crazy while the people I live with could live with them indefinitely), and then I feel gaslit by everyone who doesn't have allergic reactions to bugs and thinks I'm making a big deal out of nothing. They don't have a memory of being in elementary school and losing the ability to see out of one eye because some bug had either bitten me or stung me on the eyelid, and that made it puff up too much. They don't have a memory of having their calves or feet swell up from some bite/sting and having walking become genuinely difficult. They don't have memories of pus bubbling up in skeeter syndrome and having to have that popped and scraped out in middle school. They don't have memories of being in Japan, being unable to bend my elbow or sit properly on one thigh because of mosquitoes while their sibling fumed about logistics and were annoyed they were making such a big deal out of something.

Or maybe they do, and I'm the weird one for still being anxious! Who's to say. Regardless, I don't want to hang out in the woods, and you can't make me. I respect what she's saying, from afar, and I will help if asked, if I can do parts that aren't so direct with insects. OR someone can dress me up in a beekeeper outfit and not have me wade into ponds and promise me that the average person won't point at me and laugh when they walk by me. That's also an option.

Otherwise, despite how much I've written about this book now and how much it made me think, it was grating at times for me to get through for reasons mostly unrelated to the author and what she had written. In my desperation to get through this book, I read parts of it in ebook format and listened to other parts of it through my library, and the overwhelming throughline of motherhood, motherhood, motherhood, which is evidently very important to Kimmer and 0% important to me, triggered a familiar annoyance that comes with whenever I read or listen to something that seems to be charting a little too close to the concept of the "divine feminine" or "essentialized femininity". It got to the point where even her steady, motherly voicing, was grating on me at points. Totally unfair to her, but that's my true experience.

Motherhood is everything in this book, and honestly it seems like too much work. The father to Kimmer's children packed up and left, so she had to do all childcare, on top of caring for the land by herself, on top of her full-time job. Kimmer also relates having a very hardworking mother, which probably set up this image for her. There's a line that recounts a teaching that says women go through phases of their life as learning, then giving all they have to their children, and then to their community, so that their circle spirals out and extends beyond humans to mothering the whole earth. Sigh. I've always been allergic to this constant selfless refrain of the ideals of motherhood because I very much resent the absent men. Also, I am a more selfish person who has no parental instinct and does not want to give all of my efforts to someone else, having already lived through abusive/neglectful parents and friends with emotional needs far beyond what I could give. And I also think this is kind of impractical to set this as a goal of everyone. In practice, men will mostly get off scot-free. This is primarily my issue with reading any work that is centered around femme ideals, and it's coming up again for me. (Not saying reading work that centers masc ideals is better — it tends to be worse.) Notably, men's roles in all of this care go undescribed and unaccounted for other than like two spare individual mentions. My guess is because Kimmer is so wholly engrossed in the ideals of motherhood that she doesn't feel the need to explore that or teach it, because this book is from her perspective and what she finds important. Coming as a reader that hates motherhood, all I can hope is that someday, someone else will tell me what on earth the men are supposed to be doing and how the burden of labor can be more equal.

This post is long enough, but the last thought I have is that the entire section on Potawatomi on a language and how 70% of everything is verbs and they conjugate verbs based on an assumption of animacy and whether things are being or doing things, like "to be a bay" was fascinating. I could never learn this language seeing how I can't even learn Tâi-gí, but it's honestly so cool that I would, were I more language-brained.

Below are notes.


Skywoman

On one side of the world were people whose relationship with the living world was shaped by Skywoman, who created a garden for the well-being of all. On the other side was another woman with a garden and a tree. But for tasting its fruit, she was banished from the garden and the gates clanged shut behind her. That mother of men was made to wander in the wilderness and earn her bread by the sweat of her brow, not by filling her mouth with the sweet juicy fruits that bend the branches low. In order to eat, she was instructed to subdue the wilderness into which she was cast.

Same species, same earth, different stories. Like Creation stories everywhere, cosmologies are a source of identity and orientation to the world. They tell us who we are. We are inevitably shaped by them no matter how distant they may be from our consciousness. One story leads to the generous embrace of the living world, the other to banishment. One woman is our ancestral gardener, a cocreator of the good green world that would be the home of her descendants. The other was an exile, just passing through an alien world on a rough road to her real home in heaven.

...

As we consider these instructions, it is also good to recall that, when Skywoman arrived here, she did not come alone. She was pregnant. Knowing her grandchildren would inherit the world she left behind, she did not work for flourishing in her time only. It was through her actions of reciprocity, the give and take with the land, that the original immigrant became indigenous. For all of us, becoming indigenous to a place means living as if your children’s future mattered, to take care of the land as if our lives, both material and spiritual, depended on it.

...

In the Western tradition there is a recognized hierarchy of beings, with, of course, the human being on top—the pinnacle of evolution, the darling of Creation—and the plants at the bottom. But in Native ways of knowing, human people are often referred to as “the younger brothers of Creation.” We say that humans have the least experience with how to live and thus the most to learn—we must look to our teachers among the other species for guidance. Their wisdom is apparent in the way that they live. They teach us by example. They’ve been on the earth far longer than we have been, and have had time to figure things out. They live both above and below ground, joining Skyworld to the earth. Plants know how to make food and medicine from light and water, and then they give it away.


Wild Strawberries

Gifts from the earth or from each other establish a particular relationship, an obligation of sorts to give, to receive, and to reciprocate. The field gave to us, we gave to my dad, and we tried to give back to the strawberries. When the berry season was done, the plants would send out slender red runners to make new plants. Because I was fascinated by the way they would travel over the ground looking for good places to take root, I would weed out little patches of bare ground where the runners touched down. Sure enough, tiny little roots would emerge from the runner and by the end of the season there were even more plants, ready to bloom under the next Strawberry Moon. No person taught us this—the strawberries showed us. Because they had given us a gift, an ongoing relationship opened between us.

...

It’s funny how the nature of an object—let’s say a strawberry or a pair of socks—is so changed by the way it has come into your hands, as a gift or as a commodity. The pair of wool socks that I buy at the store, red and gray striped, are warm and cozy. I might feel grateful for the sheep that made the wool and the worker who ran the knitting machine. I hope so. But I have no inherent obligation to those socks as a commodity, as private property. There is no bond beyond the politely exchanged “thank yous” with the clerk. I have paid for them and our reciprocity ended the minute I handed her the money. The exchange ends once parity has been established, an equal exchange. They become my property. I don’t write a thank-you note to JCPenney.

But what if those very same socks, red and gray striped, were knitted by my grandmother and given to me as a gift? That changes everything. A gift creates ongoing relationship. I will write a thank-you note. I will take good care of them and if I am a very gracious grandchild I’ll wear them when she visits even if I don’t like them. When it’s her birthday, I will surely make her a gift in return. As the scholar and writer Lewis Hyde notes, “It is the cardinal difference between gift and commodity exchange that a gift establishes a feeling-bond between two people.

What I mean of course is that our human relationship with strawberries is transformed by our choice of perspective. It is human perception that makes the world a gift. When we view the world this way, strawberries and humans alike are transformed.


Potawatomi

To actually speak, of course, requires verbs, and here is where my kindergarten proficiency at naming things leaves off. English is a nounbased language, somehow appropriate to a culture so obsessed with things. Only 30 percent of English words are verbs, but in Potawatomi that proportion is 70 percent. Which means that 70 percent of the words have to be conjugated, and 70 percent have different tenses and cases to be mastered.

European languages often assign gender to nouns, but Potawatomi does not divide the world into masculine and feminine. Nouns and verbs both are animate and inanimate. You hear a person with a word that is completely different from the one with which you hear an airplane. Pronouns, articles, plurals, demonstratives, verbs—all those syntactical bits I never could keep straight in high school English are all aligned in Potawatomi to provide different ways to speak of the living world and the lifeless one. Different verb forms, different plurals, different everything apply depending on whether what you are speaking of is alive.

...

Pages blurred and my eyes settled on a word—a verb, of course: “to be a Saturday.” Pfft! I threw down the book. Since when i s Saturday a verb? Everyone knows it’s a noun. I grabbed the dictionary and flipped more pages and all kinds of things seemed to be verbs: “to be a hill,” “to be red,” “to be a long sandy stretch of beach,” and then my finger rested on wiikwegamaa: “to be a bay.” “Ridiculous!” I ranted in my head. “There is no reason to make it so complicated. No wonder no one speaks it. A cumbersome language, impossible to learn, and more than that, it’s all wrong. A bay is most definitely a person, place, or thing—a noun and not a verb.” I was ready to give up. I’d learned a few words, done my duty to the language that was taken from my grandfather. Oh, the ghosts of the missionaries in the boarding schools must have been rubbing their hands in glee at my frustration. “She’s going to surrender,” they said.

And then I swear I heard the zap of synapses firing. An electric current sizzled down my arm and through my finger, and practically scorched the page where that one word lay. In that moment I could smell the water of the bay, watch it rock against the shore and hear it sift onto the sand. A bay is a noun only if water is dead. When bay is a noun, it is defined by humans, trapped between its shores and contained by the word. But the verb wiikwegamaa—to be a bay —releases the water from bondage and lets it live. “To be a bay” holds the wonder that, for this moment, the living water has decided to shelter itself between these shores, conversing with cedar roots and a flock of baby mergansers. Because it could do otherwise— become a stream or an ocean or a waterfall, and there are verbs for that, too. To be a hill, to be a sandy beach, to be a Saturday, all are possible verbs in a world where everything is alive. Water, land, and even a day, the language a mirror for seeing the animacy of the world, the life that pulses through all things, through pines and nuthatches and mushrooms. This is the language I hear in the woods; this is the language that lets us speak of what wells up all around us. And the vestiges of boarding schools, the soap-wielding missionary wraiths, hang their heads in defeat.

This is the grammar of animacy. Imagine seeing your grandmother standing at the stove in her apron and then saying of her, “Look, it is making soup. It has gray hair.” We might snicker at such a mistake, but we also recoil from it. In English, we never refer to a member of our family, or indeed to any person, as it. That would be a profound act of disrespect. It robs a person of self hood and kinship, reducing a person to a mere thing. So it is that in Potawatomi and most other indigenous languages, we use the same words to address the living world as we use for our family. Because they are our family.

To whom does our language extend the grammar of animacy? Naturally, plants and animals are animate, but as I learn, I am discovering that the Potawatomi understanding of what it means to be animate diverges from the list of attributes of living beings we all learned in Biology 101. In Potawatomi 101, rocks are animate, as are mountains and water and fire and places. Beings that are imbued with spirit, our sacred medicines, our songs, drums, and even stories, are all animate. The list of the inanimate seems to be smaller, filled with objects that are made by people. Of an inanimate being, like a table, we say, “What is it?” And we answer Dopwen yewe. Table it is. But of apple, we must say, “ Who is that being?” And reply Mshimin yawe. Apple that being is.

Yawe—the animate to be. I am, you are, s/he is. To speak of those possessed with life and spirit we must say yawe. By what linguistic confluence do Yahweh of the Old Testament and yawe of the New World both fall from the mouths of the reverent? Isn’t this just what it means, to be, to have the breath of life within, to be the offspring of Creation? The language reminds us, in every sentence, of our kinship with all of the animate world.

English doesn’t give us many tools for incorporating respect for animacy. In English, you are either a human or a thing. Our grammar boxes us in by the choice of reducing a nonhuman being to an it, or it must be gendered, inappropriately, as a he or a she. Where are our words for the simple existence of another living being? Where is our yawe? My friend Michael Nelson, an ethicist who thinks a great deal about moral inclusion, told me about a woman he knows, a field biologist whose work is among other-than- humans. Most of her companions are not two-legged, and so her language has shifted to accommodate her relationships. She kneels along the trail to inspect a set of moose tracks, saying, “Someone’s already been this way this morning.” “Someone is in my hat,” she says, shaking out a deerfly. Someone, not something.


Together we learn to count and to say pass the salt. Someone asks, “How do you say please pass the salt?” Our teacher, Justin Neely, a young man devoted to language revival, explains that while there are several words for thank you, there is no word for please. Food was meant to be shared, no added politeness needed; it was simply a cultural given that one was asking respectfully. The missionaries took this absence as further evidence of crude manners.


Maples

The Maples each year carry out their part of the Original Instructions, to care for the people. But they care for their own survival at the same time. The buds that sensed the incipient turn of the season are hungry. For shoots that are only one millimeter long to become full-fledged leaves, they need food. So when the buds sense spring, they send a hormonal signal down the trunk to the roots, a wake-up call, telegraphed from the light world to the underworld. The hormone triggers the formation of amylase, the enzyme responsible for cleaving large molecules of starch stored in the roots into small molecules of sugar. When the concentration of sugar in the roots begins to grow, it creates an osmotic gradient that draws water in from the soil. Dissolved in this water from the spring-wet earth, the sugar streams upward as rising sap to feed the buds. It takes a lot of sugar to feed people and buds, so the tree uses its sapwood, the xylem, as the conduit. Sugar transport is usually restricted to the thin layer of phloem tissue under the bark. But in spring, before there are leaves to make their own sugar, the need is so great that xylem is called into duty as well. At no other time of year does sugar move this way, only now when it is needed. Sugar flows upstream for a few weeks in the spring. But when the buds break and leaves emerge, they start making sugar on their own and the sapwood returns to its work as the water conduit.

Because the mature leaves make more sugar than they can use right away, the sugar stream starts to flow in the opposite direction, from leaves back to roots, through the phloem. And so the roots, which fed the buds, are now fed in return by the leaves all summer long. The sugar is converted back to starch, stored in the original “root cellar.” The syrup we pour over pancakes on a winter morning is summer sunshine flowing in golden streams to pool on our plates.

...

Such a responsibility I have to these people and these trees, left to me, an unknown come to live under the guardianship of the twins, with a bond physical, emotional, and spiritual. I have no way to pay them back. Their gift to me is far greater than I have ability to reciprocate. They’re so huge as to be nearly beyond my care, although I do scatter granules of fertilizer at their feet and turn the hose on them in summer drought. Perhaps all I can do is love them. All I know to do is to leave another gift, for them and for the future, those next unknowns who will live here. I heard once that Maori people make beautiful wood sculptures that they carry long distances into the forest and leave there as a gift to the trees. And so I plant Daffodils, hundreds of them, in sunny flocks beneath the Maples, in homage to their beauty and in reciprocity for their gift.

Nanabozho made certain that the work would never be too easy. His teachings remind us that one half of the truth is that the earth endows us with great gifts, the other half is that the gift is not enough. The responsibility does not lie with the maples alone. The other half belongs to us; we participate in its transformation. It is our work, and our gratitude, that distills the sweetness.


Sweetgrass

Sweetgrass belongs to Mother Earth. Sweetgrass pickers collect properly and respectfully, for their own use and the needs of their community. They return a gift to the earth and tend to the well- being of the wiingashk. The braids are given as gifts, to honor, to say thank you, to heal and to strengthen. The sweetgrass is kept in motion. When Wally gives sweetgrass to the fire, it is a gift that has passed from hand to hand, growing richer as it is honored in every exchange.

That is the fundamental nature of gifts: they move, and their value increases with their passage. The fields made a gift of berries to us and we made a gift of them to our father. The more something is shared, the greater its value becomes. This is hard to grasp for societies steeped in notions of private property, where others are, by definition, excluded from sharing. Practices such as posting land against trespass, for example, are expected and accepted in a property economy but are unacceptable in an economy where land is seen as a gift to all.

The surprise was that the failing plots were not the harvested ones, as predicted, but the unharvested controls. The sweetgrass that had not been picked or disturbed in any way was choked with dead stems while the harvested plots were thriving. Even though half of all stems had been harvested each year, they quickly grew back, completely replacing everything that had been gathered, in fact producing more shoots than were present before harvest. Picking sweetgrass seemed to actually stimulate growth. In the first year’s harvest, the plants that grew the very best were the ones that had been yanked up in a handful. But, whether it was pinched singly or pulled in a clump, the end result was nearly the same: it didn’t seem to matter how the grass was harvested, only that it was.

Laurie’s graduate committee had dismissed this possibility from the outset. They had been taught that harvesting causes decline. And yet the grasses themselves unequivocally argued the opposite point. After the grilling Laurie received over her research proposal, you might imagine she was dreading the thesis defense. But she had one thing skeptical scientists value most: data. While Celia slept in her proud father’s arms, Laurie presented her graphs and tables to demonstrate that sweetgrass flourishes when it’s harvested and declines when it is not. The doubting dean was silent. The basket makers smiled.

Wild meadow sweetgrass grows long and fragrant when it is looked after by humans. Weeding and care for the habitat and neighboring plants strengthens its growth.


Blah, blah, motherhood:

Raking a pond provides you with a lot of mental free space for philosophizing. As I raked and plucked, it challenged my conviction that all lives are valuable, protozoan or not. As a theoretical matter, I hold this to be true, but on a practical level it gets murky, the spiritual and the pragmatic bumping heads. With every rake I knew that I was prioritizing. Short, single-cell lives were ended because I wanted a clear pond. I’m bigger, I have a rake, so I win. That’s not a worldview I readily endorse. But it didn’t keep me awake at night, or halt my efforts; I simply acknowledged the choices I was making. The best I could do was to be respectful and not let the small lives go to waste. I plucked out whatever wee beasties I could and the rest went into the compost pile, to start the cycle again as soil.

...

It came to me once again that restoring a habitat, no matter how well intentioned, produces casualties. We set ourselves up as arbiters of what is good when often our standards of goodness are driven by narrow interests, by what we want. I piled the cut brush back up near the nest in some semblance of the protective cover I had destroyed and sat on a rock, concealed on the other side of the pond, to see if she would come back. What did she think as she watched me come closer and closer, laying waste to the home she had carefully chosen, threatening her family? There are powerful forces of destruction loose in the world, advancing inexorably toward her children and mine. The onslaught of progress, well- intentioned to improve human habitat, threatens the nest I’ve chosen for my children as surely as I threatened hers. What does a good mother do?

...

The pond built my muscles, wove my baskets, mulched my garden, made my tea, and trellised my morning glories. Our lives became entwined in ways both material and spiritual. It’s been a balanced exchange: I worked on the pond and the pond worked on me, and together we made a good home.


I didn't manage to take any other notes because I was getting tired of spending time with this book and just listened to the audiobook, but I think the stuff I was thinking about was mostly summarized in the beginning. There's a few other good examples of reciprocity between humans and the plants they care for, but the sweetgrass is by far the best example.

#books #nonfiction